This article is educational and is not personal medical advice.
Pain, injury and rehabilitation are individual. A Pivotal Motion physiotherapist can assess your
specific symptoms and recommend treatment. To book a consultation, visit
pivotalmotion.physio
or call (07) 3352 5116.
Disclosure:
This post contains affiliate links.
As an Amazon Associate, Pivotal Motion Education earns from qualifying purchases.
There is no additional cost to you.
See our Affiliate Disclosure.
If your heel stabs with the first few steps out of bed, or when you stand up after a long drive, you probably want something in your shoes this week. Pivotal Motion’s physios in Newmarket, Brisbane see heel pain every week, and some bring their insoles and shoes along to the appointment. These picks are ranked on what we check when they do.
A good insole may support your arch and cushion your heel while the plantar fascia settles. It does that best alongside the load changes and exercises in our plantar fasciitis treatment guide. For the background on why the heel hurts in the first place, read what causes plantar fasciitis.
How we chose these insoles for plantar fasciitis
Arch support came first. A contoured or semi-rigid arch limits how far your arch drops when you stand, which eases the stretch along the plantar fascia. Heel cushioning came next, because padding under the heel and a deep heel cup that holds the fat pad under the heel bone can make those first steps more comfortable.
Rigidity was the third check. Superfeet uses a stabiliser cap, and firm shells like that hold the arch up better but take a week or two to feel normal. Softer foam, like the Spenco’s cushioning pods, is comfortable from the first day and flattens with months of daily wear.
For fit, we noted whether it is full length or a heel-length insert, how much room it takes up inside the shoe, and whether it replaces the insole that came with it. We also noted how many days of gradual wear each one needs before it feels normal.
Sizing varies a lot between brands. Several of these insoles come in US size bands and some are trim-to-fit. The heel cup is sized by body weight instead. Every pick was listed on Amazon AU when we checked in October 2026.
The best insoles for plantar fasciitis in Australia at a glance
Each model’s review links to its Amazon AU listing.
Footlogics Plantar Fasciitis Orthotic Insoles: Best for low arches
Features at a glance
| Type | EVA orthotic insole, velour top, Poron heel and forefoot pads |
|---|
| Arch support | Firm, under the inside of the foot |
|---|
| Length | Full |
|---|
| Sizing | Small fits EU 39 to 41 |
|---|
| Best for | Low arches, lace-up shoes and work boots |
|---|
Buy now on AmazonFootlogics is an Australian-owned company, and the NHS in England has approved it as a preferred orthotics supplier. This model is designed for heel pain.
It is a full-length orthotic insole with firm arch support under the inside of the foot. The body is EVA foam with a soft velour top layer, and there are Poron pads in the heel and forefoot for cushioning. Footlogics says it suits lace-up shoes and work boots.
Small covers EU 39 to 41 and the listing goes up to XL, so most people will need the brand’s size chart to find their band.
It suits people with flatter feet or feet that roll in when they stand. It is firmer than the Spenco or Scholl picks, so it needs a gradual break-in. If your arches are not low, that inner support may feel like too much.
Physio verdict: a sensible first orthotic insole for flatter feet, as long as you build up wear time slowly.
View the Footlogics Plantar Fasciitis Orthotic Insoles on Amazon AU
Superfeet Green: Best overall
Features at a glance
| Type | High-density foam with stabiliser cap and deep heel cup |
|---|
| Arch support | High, firm |
|---|
| Length | Full, replaces the removable liner |
|---|
| Trim to fit | Yes, if between sizes go half a size up and trim |
|---|
| Best for | High or medium arches in roomy shoes and work boots |
|---|
Buy now on AmazonSuperfeet Green is the firmest insole on this list. Superfeet now sells it as All-Purpose Support High Arch, and its spec sheet lists a high arch at max thickness, with firm cushioning. One Amazon AU bullet point calls it a low-arched insole, which does not match the brand’s own description, so go by the Superfeet spec.
Underneath, a stabiliser cap wraps the heel and arch, and the sculpted heel cup keeps your heel sitting in the middle of the insole, which is where its heel stability comes from. Above that is high-density foam without much soft padding, so you feel the support before you feel any cushioning.
It replaces the removable liner, and Superfeet says it fits best in roomy to moderate-fitting footwear such as running shoes and work boots. Amazon AU sells it in US size ranges. If you are between sizes, Superfeet suggests going half a size up and trimming it down.
It suits people with high arches, or medium arches, who find soft insoles flatten under them, and people on their feet in boots all day. If you have flat feet the high arch and firm shell can feel aggressive, and everyone should expect a longer break-in than with the softer picks.
Physio verdict: excellent support and heel stability for higher arches. Wear it for an hour a day at first and add time from there.
View Superfeet Green on Amazon AU
Spenco Total Support Original: Best cushioned support for standing all day
Features at a glance
| Type | Cushioned insole with Polysorb stability cradle |
|---|
| Arch support | Arch support plus metatarsal support |
|---|
| Length | Full |
|---|
| Key features | 3-pod cushioning, forefoot crash pad, deep heel cupping |
|---|
| Best for | Long shifts standing on hard floors |
|---|
Buy now on AmazonIf your heel pain builds through a long shift on hard floors in retail or nursing, the Spenco is the pick to try. It is softer underfoot than the Superfeet, so most people find it comfortable sooner.
The Original has a semi-rigid arch support and a stability cradle with deep heel cupping. Underneath are three cushioning pods of different hardness placed under key areas of the foot, plus a pad under the ball of the foot and a support behind it to take some pressure off the forefoot. Spenco describes it as wear-moldable.
Spenco also sells Total Support Max, which has a rigid arch, and Total Support Thin for low-volume shoes. Check you have the Original before you buy. Sizes are US men’s and women’s bands.
The catch is wear. The cushioning compresses with heavy daily use, so it needs replacing sooner than a firm shell, and it adds volume inside the shoe.
Physio verdict: the most comfortable of the supportive picks for long days on hard floors.
View the Spenco Total Support Original on Amazon AU
Dr. Scholl’s Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Orthotics: Best budget
Features at a glance
| Type | Insole with reinforced arch and shock-absorbing heel cushion |
|---|
| Arch support | Reinforced, less rigid than a firm shell |
|---|
| Length | Full |
|---|
| Trim to fit | Yes |
|---|
| Best for | Casual shoes, sneakers and work boots |
|---|
Buy now on AmazonThis is a low-cost way to find out whether arch support and heel cushioning help your heel at all. It is a full-length insole with a reinforced arch and a shock-absorbing heel cushion, and it fits casual shoes and work boots.
It comes in two broad size bands, women’s 6 to 10 and men’s 8 to 13. You trim it along the printed outline near the toes until it lies flat in the shoe without bunching. Dr. Scholl’s says to replace the pair every six months or at the first signs of wear.
It suits people with mild heel pain who want to test an insole before spending more, and anyone who needs a spare pair for a second pair of shoes. It is less rigid than the Superfeet, so you get less arch control. The broad size bands also make the fit less precise than a brand that sizes in half sizes.
Physio verdict: a reasonable low-cost way to test whether an insole helps your heel pain.
View Dr. Scholl’s Plantar Fasciitis Pain Relief Orthotics on Amazon AU
Scholl In-Balance Heel Orthotic Insoles: Best for tight or dress shoes
Features at a glance
| Type | Dual-layer gel heel cup with heel raise |
|---|
| Arch support | Internal arch support |
|---|
| Length | Heel |
|---|
| Trim to fit | Yes, sized in AU sizes (Medium is AU 7 to 8.5) |
|---|
| Best for | Work and dress shoes with no room for a full insole |
|---|
Buy now on AmazonThe In-Balance Heel is a heel-length insert. Scholl’s own comparison lists its shape as a heel cup, while other models in the range are 3/4 or full length. It has a dual-layer gel heel cup with an internal arch support, and the heel sits on a raise. Scholl sizes it in AU sizes, with Medium covering AU 7 to 8.5, and says it can be trimmed and should be worn in gradually.
The short shape is the point. It leaves the front of the shoe untouched, so it fits work shoes and dress shoes that have no removable insole and no spare room at the toes. The trade-off is that it supports less of your foot than a full-length orthotic insole.
It suits people who have to wear work or dress shoes and cannot fit a thicker insole. It can slide around in shoes without a firm heel counter, and the heel raise lifts your heel, so check your heel stays in the shoe when you walk.
Physio verdict: the practical choice for shoes where a full-length insole will not fit.
View the Scholl In-Balance Heel Orthotic Insoles on Amazon AU
Tuli’s Heavy Duty Heel Cups: Best heel cup
Features at a glance
| Type | Double-ribbed waffle heel cup |
|---|
| Arch support | None |
|---|
| Length | Heel, sits on top of your existing insole |
|---|
| Sizing | By body weight, Regular is under 175 lb (about 79 kg) |
|---|
| Best for | Heel cushioning on hard floors |
|---|
Buy now on AmazonA heel cup is the right buy when your pain sits under the heel more than along the arch, or when you already have shoes you like and do not want to swap the insole. Tuli’s Heavy Duty cup sits on top of your existing insole, so it fits most shoes and moves between pairs easily.
The cup is a double-ribbed waffle design. Tuli’s says the larger, higher waffle cells take the first impact of heel strike and the lower, denser cells take the final pressure spike.
It is sized by body weight, with Regular for people under 175 lb (about 79 kg) and a Large for heavier people. Tuli’s also sells a Classic version on Amazon AU.
It suits people on hard floors who want a low-cost add-on to try first. It gives no arch support. It also lifts the heel slightly, so check your heel does not slip out of the back of the shoe.
Physio verdict: a simple add-on for heel cushioning, and you can pair it with arch support if you need both.
View Tuli’s Heavy Duty Heel Cups on Amazon AU
How to choose the right insole for plantar fasciitis
Start with where it hurts. If your pain is worst with the first steps of the day and runs along the arch, start with an arch-supporting insole such as the Footlogics. If it sits mainly under the heel and builds on hard floors, a cushioned insole like the Spenco or a Tuli’s heel cup is a reasonable first step.
Firmness comes next, and body weight matters here. Soft foam flattens faster under heavier people and long shifts, so a firm shell like the Superfeet holds up better for them. If you have already tried a firm insole and could not put up with it, go softer with the Spenco.
Gel insoles are a common question. The gel cushions the heel and helps with shock absorption, but on its own it gives little arch support, so for most people with plantar fasciitis pain a gel insert does less than a supportive insole. The Scholl In-Balance Heel gets around this by putting an arch support inside its gel heel cup.
Take the existing insole out of the shoe you wear most and lay the new one on top of it before you commit. If the shoe has no removable insole, a short insert like the Scholl is the realistic option. Once the new insole is in, walk around and check your heel still sits down in the back of the shoe and your toes have enough room.
If your pain is mild, try the Dr. Scholl’s or a heel cup first and spend more only if it helps. If the shoe itself is worn out, replace the shoe rather than forcing an insole into it.
How to break in and use plantar fasciitis insoles safely
Wear a new pair for about an hour on day one, then add an hour or so each day over one to two weeks. Some awareness under the arch is normal in that time. New pain elsewhere, such as your knee or hip, is not, and neither are blisters, so stop and check the fit if either shows up.
Put the insoles in the shoes you use most. If you walk barefoot on tiles at home, wear supportive shoes or slippers with an insole indoors too, since the first steps of the day are often the worst.
Check your insoles every 6 to 12 months of daily use, and replace them when the cushioning has flattened or the shell has cracked.
Talk to a health professional before using a new insole if you have diabetes or reduced feeling in your feet (our diabetic foot article explains why), or if you have circulation problems.
See a physio rather than buying another insole if you notice any of the following:
Heel pain that started after a fall or a jump
Pain at night or when you are resting
Swelling in the heel, especially with redness or heat
Numbness or pins and needles in the foot
A burning feeling in the foot
No improvement after a few weeks of using an insole and easing your load
Stretches and taping are part of the wider treatment plan. This is general guidance, not personal advice.
When off-the-shelf insoles are enough and when to get assessed
For most people, an off-the-shelf insole is a reasonable first step. A 2018 systematic review and meta-analysis in the British Journal of Sports Medicine (Rasenberg and colleagues, 20 trials) found no difference in short-term pain between prefabricated plantar fasciitis orthotics and custom orthotics. The same review found that orthoses on their own did not outperform sham insoles or other conservative care, which is why insoles are only one part of treating plantar fasciitis. Load changes and exercise do most of the work. The latest research on plantar fasciitis covers the wider evidence.
Book an assessment if your pain has not eased after a few weeks with an insole, if you have tried more than one insole without any change, or if the pain is changing the way you walk. A physio for plantar fasciitis can work out what is driving the pain and set an exercise plan. They can also tell you whether a different insole or a referral for custom orthotics is worth considering.